Three quarters of an appellation |
The Layon river, which runs into the Loire just downstream from Angers, is the source of some gorgeous wine. It is best known for its sweet wine, made from noble rot-affected or sun-dried (passerillé) chenin blanc. The douceur Angevine which permeates its skies is a tad deceptive, however, as the valley has been beset by a major shitfight for a couple of decades.
A decree of 18 February 1950 created the AOC Coteaux de Layon. Simple enough, isn’t it? Hang on; there’s a simple way of doing anything and a French way. The appellation of 1700 hectares included plots from 6 communes and a hamlet, which were given the right to tag their village name on the label. One of these communes is Rochefort-sur-Loire. The hamlet is called Chaume, entirely within Rochefort-sur-Loire.
Hmm. So, as well as the simple AOC Coteaux de Layons, we have AOC Coteaux de Layon Rochefort-sur-Loire, AOC Coteaux de Layon Chaume and the five other villages.
Let’s now run our magnifying glass over Chaume, as it has gained special status in recognition of its reputation for quality, and is the source of all the brawls.
According to a medieval custom, the local Lords took a quarter of the production as taxes, the quart. After a while, though, they noticed that a particular 70-hectare part of the Chaume slopes produced the best grapes, so they eventually managed to purloin their quarter from just there. This became known as the Quarts de Chaume. And its reputation stuck well even after all the Lords had been bisected during the Revolution. It had effectively become a separate appellation.
It didn’t take the owners of plots in the Quarts de Chaume long to get a decree of their own. By 1954 there were therefore two “Chaume” appellations: the AOC Coteaux de Layon Chaume and the even loftier AOC Quarts de Chaume.
A tangle of hierarchy is a lovely thing. But it’s better still if you’re at the top of it. By the 1980’s, the Coteaux Chaumes were lobbying to be called just AOC Chaume, which would have deftly nudged the Quarts to one side. After two battles in the Courts and numerous compromises, the authorities have finally come up with a solution. The Quarts de Chaume will be elevated to grand cru status (in the great Burgundy tradition), the first in the Loire. The others will be called Coteaux de Layon Premier Cru Chaume.
Everyone should be happy with this. In the great tradition you now have four levels, so there’s a lot of others to look down on. I would have thought that the Quarts folk would be particularly happy: if you were to become Quarts de Chaume Grand Cru, you’d snap your file shut with a satisfied grunt, wouldn’t you? The addition of the Premier Cru to the others comes across to me as a consolation prize.

Layons lined up for tasting. The labels were different year from year, in line with all of the confusion
But I heard the rumour this week that someone from the Quarts has contested the decree. No-one could tell me the grounds, and they didn’t seem at all surprised. They’d seen it all before.
I’m going to try to get to the bottom of this one. I’m curious. Vive la difference! Vive la contestation! And I’m also a tad jealous, regretting now that I’d gave up my legal practice when I left Australia. There seems to be a lot of work for wine-savvy lawyers in la Patrie! This couldn’t have happened in Australia. Over there, your status depends on the price you command. Simple.
Perhaps just a bit too simple.

























Angélique Léon makes only one cuvée, simply called « rouge », from her 6.2 hectares of Cabernet Franc grown on the western edge of the appellation in deep alluvial sands. 2010 was a « clean » year, requiring little grape selection. Her delicious wine would have been ideal with the dessert of strawberry soup (during which a far more robust red was served) as it was round and silky, designed to be drunk young. At 6.20€, a deal. Call her on 02 47 58 92 70 or 06 66 49 64 32.
The inverse of that Couly-Dutheil, the Domaine Charles Joguet Clos du Chene Vert 2009 is designed for the long haul. This rich and powerful wine has seen quite a bit of oak: 3/4 has been aged in barrels that have been used twice and three times. From sunny slopes of mixed sand and clay, it is far from ready to drink, but will be remarkable in ten years time. 19€. 02 47 58 55 53.
Finally, if you think that the Loire valley cannot create huge wines, grab a Danae rouge 2008 from the Domaine les Chesnaies. Even in such a difficult year, this organic and recently bio-dynamic estate has managed to produce a wine with plenty of acidity yet 14 degrees of alcohol. Global warming wasn’t supposed to turn the Loire into Chateauneuf-du-Pape quite yet! Although the wine spends 24 months in oak (25% new) the wood is already absorbed. It just needs a few years to fall into place. Well worth the wait, I’m sure. 14.50€. Tel: 02 47 93 13 79.





